Hobby or Business? Understand how to establish a profit-driven strategy that legitimizes your business.
Hobby or Business? Understand how to establish a profit-driven strategy that legitimizes your business.
October 06, 2023

Owning a business is an exciting journey filled with highs and lows. Establishing a clear, profit-driven strategy is one key factor that can tilt the scales toward success. The recent tax court case, Gregory v. Commissioner, highlighted how blurring the lines between hobbies and genuine business ventures can have significant financial implications. Not only did this case underscore the importance of clear delineation, but it also highlighted the potential tax pitfalls of not doing so. In this article, we’ll cover how to ensure your venture is seen as a legitimate business and not just a pricey pastime.

Understanding the Hobby Loss Conundrum

The “hobby loss” rules have made waves in the tax world, affecting many business activities, from horse breeding to charter boat operations and even Airbnb rentals. Only activities classified as what the IRS refers to as “engaged in for profit” are able to deduct expenses associated with the work. In other words, to be considered “engaged in for profit” means you set out with the intention of your business and activity to generate a profit. If the IRS determines the activity was not “engaged in for profit,” your ability to deduct associated expenses will be impacted. If your venture is potentially labeled a hobby, you could find yourself in a situation where you’re reporting full income without the benefit of crucial deductions.

In the case of Gregory discussed above, the business owner reported gross income equaling the business expenses, yet he couldn’t use the deductions due to the hobby classification. As a result, the ruling reduced his profit and increased the business’s taxes due, which is not the ideal scenario for any business owner.

Establishing a Profit Motive

The U.S. Tax Court and the Internal Revenue Service use a range of factors to determine whether a business truly has a profit motive. Remember, while starting a business around your passion is fantastic, the profit motive is what separates it as a sustainable business rather than an expensive hobby.

Four steps can make it a clear and recurrent theme in your business strategy.

  • Clear Records: Maintain precise and consistent bookkeeping. Separate business from personal expenses and keep a dedicated business bank account. This is more than just good practice; it’s a way to show that you operate in a business-like manner.
  • Consult the Experts: Engage with industry consultants and tax professionals. Their insights can help steer your ship clear of any hobby loss icebergs, and even a history of losses can be justified if you have expert testimonies or guidance.
  • Adapt and Thrive: Continually evolve your business strategy to ensure profitability. Being adaptable is key in the ever-changing world of business. This means adapting your operations and ensuring legal formalities and structures are in place.
  • Written Plans are Gold: Experience suggests a documented plan to achieve profitability may be a game-changer. This isn’t just paperwork—it’s a roadmap to success and could be your best defense against being recharacterized as a hobby.

Why This Matters to Business Owners

When your business displays a consistent profit-driven strategy, you’re protecting yourself from potential tax pitfalls and setting your venture up for long-term success. Adhering to these guidelines reflects solid business judgment that can benefit your company in the long run. Remember the consequences: a misclassified hobby can lead to reporting full income without deducing the expenses.

Take the Next Step

Are you currently engaged in a business activity that could toe the line between hobby and legitimate venture? Chat with your tax advisor. Discuss your profit-driven strategies and plans, taking lessons from the Gregory case. Continual reflection and adaptation, even in the face of enjoyable or recreational activities, are the keys to solidifying your business’s market placement.

The line between passion and profit is a fine one. Yet, with a clear, profit-driven strategy and awareness of nuances like the “hobby loss” rules, you can ensure your business thrives in today’s competitive marketplace. Stay informed, stay adaptable, and always keep that profit motive at the forefront of your business operations.

Treasury Circular 230 Disclosure

Unless expressly stated otherwise, any federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used, and cannot be used or relied upon, for the purpose of avoiding penalties under the Internal Revenue Code, or for promoting, marketing, or recommending any transaction or matter addressed herein.

Get updates sent to your inbox.
Sign up today to receive a free consultation or sign up for our editor's newsletter.
Back to Top